|
(July 10, 1899 - January 9, 1936)
Known
as "the great lover," he rivaled even the great Rudolph Valentino as
a box office draw. Though he was often cited as one of the high
profile examples of an actor who was unsuccessful in making the
transition to talkies, his decline as a star in fact had as much to
do with studio politics and money as did the sound of his screen
voice.
Born John Cecil Pringle in Logan, Utah to stock company actor
parents, he struggled through a childhood of abuse and neglect
before coming to Hollywood as a teenager. He first found work as an
extra with the Thomas Ince Studios, and soon became a favorite of
Maurice Tourneur, who also hired him to write and direct several
pictures. He quickly rose through the ranks, building his reputation
as an actor in such films as Heart o' the Hills opposite Mary
Pickford. In 1921, Gilbert signed a three year contract with Fox
Film Corporation, where he was cast as a romantic leading man.
In 1924, he moved to Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, where he became a
full-fledged star with such high-profile films as His Hour directed
by King Vidor and written by Elinor Glyn; He Who Gets Slapped
(1924), co-starring Lon Chaney, Sr. and Norma Shearer, and directed
by Victor Sjöström; and The Merry Widow (1925) directed by Erich von
Stroheim and co-starring Mae Murray. In 1925, Gilbert was once again
directed by Vidor in the war epic The Big Parade, which became the
second highest grossing silent film in cinema history. His
performance in this film made him a major star. The following year,
Vidor reunited Gilbert with two of his co-stars from that picture,
Renée Adorée and Karl Dane, for the film La Bohème which also
starred Lillian Gish.
In 1926, Gilbert made Flesh and the Devil, his first film with Greta
Garbo. They soon began a very public relationship, much to the
delight of their fans. Gilbert planned to marry her, but Garbo
changed her mind and never showed up for the ceremony. Despite their
rocky off-screen relationship, they continued to generate box-office
revenue for the studio, and MGM paired them in two more silents Love
(1927), a modern adaptation of Anna Karenina, and A Woman of Affairs
(1928). The former film was slyly advertised by MGM as "Garbo and
Gilbert in 'Love'".
Throughout his time at MGM, Gilbert frequently clashed with studio
head Louis B. Mayer over creative, social and financial matters. One
crucial event occurred on September 8, 1926. While guests were
waiting for Garbo to show up for a proposed double wedding ceremony
-- Garbo and Gilbert with the director King Vidor and his fiancee,
actress Eleanor Boardman -- Mayer allegedly made a crude remark
about Garbo to the distraught Gilbert that caused him to fly into a
rage and he physically attacked the mogul. Rumor had it that after
that event, Gilbert's career began its downward slide. This story
has been disputed by some historians, despite its having been
reported over a period of twenty years by one major eyewitness, the
other bride, Eleanor Boardman who described Mayer's final look at
Gilbert as "terrifying". Gilbert did have a powerful supporter in
production head Irving Thalberg. The two were old friends and
Thalberg made efforts to reinvigorate Gilbert's career, but
Thalberg's failing health probably limited such efforts.
With the coming of sound, John Gilbert first spoke in the
all-talking musical Hollywood Revue of 1929. He appeared in a Romeo
and Juliet Technicolor sequence along with Norma Shearer in which
they first played the part straight and then modernized it.
Reviewers for the film did not note any problems with Gilbert's
voice at this time and, in fact, some praised it. Gilbert's career
faltered mainly due to the quality of the projects he was given --
though it is certainly true that his light tenor voice and precise
stage diction did not match his dashing screen persona, or what his
many fans had imagined him to sound like.
According to film reviews of the day, audiences actually laughed at
Gilbert's overly ardent love-making in his first all-talking feature
His Glorious Night (1929). Like a number of other romance-oriented
early talkies, the dialogue was unintentionally ludicrous and the
film played more like a comedy gone bad than a romantic drama. In
one scene, Gilbert keeps kissing his leading lady while saying over
and over again "I love you". This scene was famously later parodied
in the MGM musical Singin' in the Rain (1952) where a preview of the
fictional The Dueling Cavalier flops disasterously.
Although Gilbert was given better roles in his later films, his
career never recovered from this disaster. The film was released
throughout the country to laughing audiences and his image as a
great lover was tarnished. His Glorious Night has never been shown
on television by Turner Entertainment due to the fact that MGM sold
the rights to Paramount for a remake, and Universal -- which
currently owns the rights to all pre-1948 Paramount films -- has not
done anything with it.
In 1932 MGM made the film Downstairs from Gilbert's original story,
in which Gilbert played against type as a scheming, blackmailing
chauffeur. The film was well received by critics, but did nothing to
restore Gilbert's popularity. Shortly after making the film he
married co-star Virginia Bruce; the couple divorced in 1934.
Gilbert starred opposite Garbo for the last time in Queen Christina
(1933) directed by Rouben Mamoulian. Garbo was top-billed and
Gilbert's name beneath the title. Although his scenes with Garbo are
excellent the picture failed to revive his career, with his next
film, The Captain Hates the Sea, being his last.
John Gilbert has a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame at 1755 Vine
Street and in 1994, he was honored with his image on a United States
postage stamp designed by caricaturist Al Hirschfeld. |